2012년 6월 15일 금요일

National Testing Should be put to an End

NCLB test in U.S.

GCSE in England & Northern Ireland

수능 in Korea

National Testing Should be put to an End
    Many countries like England, United States, and Korea require students to take national exams to measure how much students have learned. National testing has huge impact on education within a country because most governments use the result of the test to subsidize or penalize schools. While many governments are still claiming that national testing is beneficial and implementing national test, national testing should be put to an end. National testing clearly has limitations and has negative side effects. Since government only provides financial support to schools which accepts national testing and discriminates schools based on how well their students perform, it imposes burden on schools and teachers. Teachers might be forced or induced to focus overly on materials that are relevant to the test. Also, national testing is a poor measure of student learning and is an inadequate measure of how much students have learned.
National Testing inevitably induces teachers to 'teach to the test', rather than teach life skills. National testing imposes burden on teachers and induce teachers to teach for tests, not for essential skills that students must acquire in school. Teachers might concentrate more on materials that are relevant to tests, or even make students only memorize to score higher. Moreover, subjects not covered or less important in the national testing might be taught cursorily although they are equally as important as other subjects. National testing tests subjects like writing, grammar, science, or math but can’t test subjects like art, music and sports due to the massive scale and equity of the test. Those subjects that are not tested on standardized tests might be ignored by schools and budgets might be reduced. According to the editorial in the internet newspaper The Daily Campus, after requiring high school test in grades nine through 11 in America by president Bush negative consequences followed
Teachers are now forced to focus their instruction on the tests, which are often watered-down and don't adequately indicate a student's proficiency. As teachers and administrators face the pressure of meeting the federally mandated proficiency standards, important student classes and activities have been reduced or eliminated. Art, music, physical education, social studies and other important subjects not tested have taken a back seat to intensive instruction geared specifically toward standardized tests;…(15-20)
Moreover, according to the article in the Time magazine “Is That Your Final Answer?,” teachers had to curtail field trips, elective courses and even student visits to the bathroom-all in an effort to cram more test prep into the school day(Morse 1). Students lost their chance to see the world and study comfortably because of the test. School shouldn’t be where students learn to score higher, but should be a place where students learn essential life skills.
     Moreover, national testing is inadequate measure of student learning. National, standardized tests measure all students in the nation with the same test. It does not consider students’ academic ability or how fast a student can learn. As a result, it ends up inappropriate for both talented and untalented students. The test is too easy for students with high academic ability, but it’s too hard for students with low academic ability. For instance, according to One-size-fits-all exams fail the worst as well as the best, the article published in The Telegraph by John Clare, by 2002, 90% of students at the best schools got the top grade, whilst 300,000 of the United Kingdom's worst pupils failed to pass (Clare 1). As a result, national testing discourages students who learn slowly compare to other students. The article also mentions that the test “has not only become too easy for the academically able, but it is still too difficult for the bottom 40 per cent, who cry out for proper vocational courses to help them make sense of their last three years of compulsory schooling”(Clare 1).
Advocates of national test argue that it ensures all students learn the same, essential skills and information. However, it does not. Numerous essential skills and knowledge like confidence, public speaking skills, academic depth, creativity and many others are unable to be measured by testing. Thus, national testing cannot ensure that students really learn important and essential skills in life. There is a more serious issue. National testing impedes students from learning import and essential skills and knowledge. As I mentioned above in the second paragraph, national testing makes teachers primarily concentrate on scoring higher, rather than teaching really important things in life. In addition to that, national testing alters the true meaning of education, thus leading students to lose interest in learning. In the article Is That Your Final Answer also mentions that “the tests have spawned an epidemic of distressing headlines: students failing--and being held back--en masse; frenzied parents enrolling first-graders in professional test-prep courses”(Morse ). National testing makes students study for the test, attend stressful prep courses thus making them lose interest in learning and studying voluntarily. There is another danger to the national testing. Testing creates heated competition between schools, teachers and parents. That means that there is a huge chance that students might be judged by their parents, teachers and schools by their grades. National testing make students lose interest in learning and creates effects that is exactly opposite of what is originally intended.
     As shown above, national testing is not at all beneficial to the education. National testing spoils the original purpose of education. Despite the fact that many governments are implementing national testing, I strongly believe that national testing should be banned.



Works Cited
"No Child Left Behind a flawed system." The Daily Campus 21 Feb. 2005. Web. 15 June 2012. .
Clare, John. "One-size-fits-all exams fail the worst as well as the best." The Telegraph 5 Aug. 2003: 1. Web. 15 June 2012. .
Morse, Jodie, Ann Blackman, Dan Cray, Mitch Frank, and Maggie Sieger. "Is That Your Final Answer?" TIME 19 June 2000: 1-3. Web. 15 June 2012. .


2012년 6월 4일 월요일

Step 2 : THIS HOUSE WOULD END NATIONAL TESTING


     Can national testing really measure how much students have learned? National testing clearly has limitations and it has some negative side effects. Since government only provides financial support to schools which accepts national testing and discriminates schools based on how well their students perform, it imposes burden on schools. Schools might only teach materials relevant to the test or simply teach how to get a good score.

2012년 6월 3일 일요일

Step 3 : Three Arguments

Points For


1. National testing encourages teachers to 'teach to the test', rather than teach life skills


2. National, standardized tests are a poor measure of student learning


Points Against


3. National testing will ensure all students learn the same, essential skills and information

Step 1 : THIS HOUSE WOULD END NATIONAL TESTING

     National testing of schools requires schools to test their children every year to measure how much they have learned. The government only gives money to schools which do the testing. The goal of national testing is to compare students in different schools and give extra money to those schools with students who are not doing as well. There are also penalties for principles of schools who have done badly for several years. Parents at failing schools also have the right to move their children to a different school .
     Many people believe national testing is wrong and will not achieve its aim. They argue that teachers and parents should be trusted with control of schools, not the government. Others argue that the only way to know how schools and students are performing is to compare them against schools and students elsewhere in the country. Some people nevertheless want national testing, so that all children sit the same test regardless of where they live, as they do in countries like the UK and France.

2012년 5월 20일 일요일

Photoessay


     
A BIg FIsh


      It was when I was 4th grade in elementary school. My father and I woke up very early around 2 am to go fishing. The night before, my father told me that he was going fishing with his co workers and asked me to come with him. Of course, I said yes. We were going to the West Sea, and we arrived at the port around 4am. My father introduced me to his co-workers and bought some bait, hooks, and everything we need. The boat set off around 6am. While moving to the destination, I saw beautiful sunrise over the horizon. I was very excited.

When the boat arrived at the spot, we started fishing and waited for the fish to take the bait. Unfortunately, we didn’t catch much fish contrary to our expectations. However, as I vaguely remember, I wasn’t disappointed or felt boring because I was really excited that I was actually fishing, and I was spending time with my father. We thought we weren't very lucky that day because we caught relatively few compare to other days. After we waited several hours, my father got a bite. He carefully pulled the rod and finally got the fish onto the boat. He was glad that it was pretty big, and I was glad too. He told me to hold the fish and took a photo with me.
   
     We went several more fishing after that day. To me, my father is like a friend. Although he was strict when he had to, he tried to be my companion, rather than a supervisor. My father loved to travel with me and my sister and he showed the world as much as possible. We traveled many places on almost every weekends and experienced many things. One day in the winter, he drove me three hours all the way to Cherwon, Gangwon province to show me migratory birds

Through these experiences I was able to broaden my sight and develop my mind. I guess it wasn’t easy for him to travel on weekends after working very hard on weekdays, and when he really needs some rest. Some teenagers of my age have difficulty discussing their problems with parents because they are uncomfortable with their parents. Since my father always tried to get close to me, I had no problems communicating with my father and able to discuss my problems freely with him. 

     As I grew up., my father and I got busy with our own businesses and we rarely had a chance to be together. Naturally, we couldn’t travel together or spend time on weekends together. Now, we can’t even meet often since I moved into dormitory. However, memories of great times spent with my father never fade away. These memories are very precious to me and make me smile when I try to recall those memories. When I see my father, I learn a lot about fatherliness and remind myself that I would become a good father and do just like my father when I have a son.


Walmart Synthesis Essay : Shopping at Walmart is Unethica






    Nobody hates low prices, and pursuing low prices is not a bad thing at all. Especially during recent economic recessions, lower and middle class consumers are eager to save money by purchasing cheaper products. We all learn in our economics class that it is very natural for rational people to buy products that are cheaper than the other. Thus, many people view the prosperity of Walmart as an inevitable consequence of capitalism. However, Walmart has grown so powerful and influential that its obsession with lower price is harming the global society as a whole. Despite the fact that we can’t blame people for pursuing low prices, it is unethical to shop at Walmart. In this essay, I want to explore reasons with solid evidences why the shopping at Walmart is unethical.
     To begin, by pursuing low prices society is not benefited economically. In most cases, pursuing low price results in positive consequence by expediting competitions between the firms. Some people bring similar logic to the case of Walmart. For instance, Tom Van Riper wrote in his article “Wal-Mart Is Good for You” that an exchange of goods at low prices benefits everyone and also in the case of Walmart, it seems evident that its model of low prices brings more choice to consumers. But since Walmart is so powerful that it’s almost in the state of monopoly, the low price of Walmart is harmful to the economy. The more ordinary people shop at Walmart, the more local businesses shrink and close down. Thus, it breaks local communities and, as a result, reduces the purchasing power of ordinary consumers. The economic status of a nation depends largely on the household’s ability to buy and consume products. Walmart is making a negative impact on the economy of a nation by destroying the economy of households. As John Lanchester mentioned in his article “The Price of Pickles,” the poverty rate was higher in the counties with Walmart compare to counties without Walmart. Walmart creates and destroys jobs at the same time, and it seems that it’s destroying more jobs than it is creating. To add, Walmart is abusing their monopolistic position to distort the market and expand their business. They are now so powerful that they can even control the price in a market. For instance, as also demonstrated in “The Price of Pickles,” Walmart is selling products like pickles and salmon at such a ridiculously low price to the point that it’s excluding its competitors out of business and creating their own market. The pursuit of short term benefits of consumers is gradually harming the economy in a long term.
     Accordingly, shopping at Walmart is currently creating social problems that are not only limited to economic aspects. The biggest issue is violation of human rights. Walmart is so obsessed with price that it is paying less attention (or intentionally ignoring) the basic rights of its employees. Especially, the workers in developing nations who are not under the protection of law are exploited.As “The price of Pickles” mentions, workers in Bangladesh work 14 hours a day and earn only 13 cents per hour. Consumers are deliberately supporting these violations of Walmart by buying their products. Workers in the US are also receiving low wages and not getting any benefit from health insurance.
Furthermore, I want to point out the relationship of Walmart with its subcontractors. Just like many gigantic corporation, many small corporations rely on Walmart. Essentially, five to ten million people worldwide are involved in a deal with Walmart. As stated in Nathan Newman’s “Taking on Walmart and Its Subcontractors,” Walmart is exploiting 20,000 of its subcontractors and creating a global sweatshop.  All these problems are rooted on Wal-Mart’s irresponsible obsession with low prices. Any act that sacrifices other people’s happiness for the sake of their own happiness can be blamed as unethical. Buying products at Walmart is not an exception.
     To conclude, consumers must realize there are several reasons why buying products at Walmart is not ethical. Shopping at Walmart is surely convenient and practical, but it is selfish and irresponsible at the same time. In order to stop the side effects that Walmart is making, consumers can either wait for Walmart to change their price-centered policy or actively take part in the movement by avoiding unethical consumption. Considering the fact that the company’s tradition and management philosophy is very firm since its foundation, it is highly unlikely that Walmart would change its policy. No matter how powerful Walmart is, their success and policy depends on its consumers. By avoiding unethical consumptions, we can be responsible consumers.

Works Cited
Lanchester, John. "The Price of Pickles." London Review of Books 22 June 2006. Web. 6 Mar. 2012.
Riper, Tom V. "Wal-Mart Is Good For You." Forbes.com 10 Jan. 2008. Web. 6 Mar. 2012.
Newman, Nathan. "TAKING ON WAL-MART AND ITS SUBCONTRACTORS." NATHAN NEWMAN 1 June 2004. Web. 6 Mar. 2012.

2012년 4월 3일 화요일

Three sides to every story.


1st person - Junsu

I came back into my room around 5:30, and it was a terrible day. I missed my morning exercise today. Because of this, I was in a terrible mood for the entire day. I asked my roommate Minho to wake me up this morning but he didn’t. Was he so apathetic to forget my request, or did he ignore me on purpose? It would probably be the latter. I feel that all he cares about is studying and his grades. As I walk through the door, I see another roommate, Han. He is doing something with his computer. He is so pathetic. How can he be so lethargic and stupid? Then I see Minho. He is studying. I am really amazed. He is like a studying machine, and he doesn’t need to rest. I feel a little disgusted.  Minho sees me and asks, “Did you check Mr. Kim’s essay grades? It’s posted on the Internet” “Why do you ask?” I reply abruptly. “I just let you know” He answers. Then I speculate that he is asking because he got a good grade, and he wants to show off.
Originally I planned to take a little nap before I eat dinner, but animosity and jealousy against Minho makes me sit in front of the desk. Ok. I determined to study, but what should I do? Suddenly, I remembered like a week ago, our math teacher Mr. Hickson has announced that he would be collecting our math notebooks to check our homework tomorrow. I studied for a while, and left the notebook on the desk and when to the cafeteria for dinner. After I returned from cafeteria, I tried to work on the homework again. However, to my surprise, my math notebook was not on the desk! I looked around to find it, but I couldn’t find it. Then, the person immediately came up in my mind was Minho.
*             *             *
3rd person – Minho’s point of view
      Minho skipped his lunch and stayed in the room. As Minho is studying, Junsu comes in and searches for something. After a while, Junsu turns to him and accuses him with a very excited face. “Where is my math notebook?” Minho replies, “I don’t know.” “Oh, really? You don’t know?” Junsu is very persistent and makes a sarcastic comment. Minho’s face is turning red and he reacts with irritated voice “Are you suspecting me? “ Finally, Junsu is very angry and shouts at Minho. “I know that you are selfish and have a strong sense of rivalry, but you shouldn’t ruin other people’s work!”
Minho doesn’t reply to that. He seems like he has something to say but he does not say anything.  Minho opens the door and gets out. After a while, Junsu gets out of the room too.

*             *             *
2nd person - Han’s point of view
     You are surprised watching them fight. Yesterday, you asked Junsu to borrow his math notebook, but he rejected you. You were very humiliated. Even before that moment, you felt alone and ignored by your roommates. You are not good at studying then your roommates were, so they implicitly ignored and belittled you. When they were talking about grades or academic things they naturally excluded you because your grades were bad. So you decided to put him in a trouble. You stole Junsu’s math notebook when he was eating dinner and hid it in your secret place. You were so careful that Minho didn’t even realize that you were stealing Junsu’s notebook.
You didn’t expect that this was going to get this big. You are surprised with Junsu’s reactions and how Minho responds to it. Junsu immediately speculates that Minho stole his notebook.

*             *             *
1st person – Junsu
The next day, the math class began. I couldn’t find my math notebook. Minho must have stolen it.  I still can’t forgive Minho. Mr. Hickson came in and began talking about the homework. I began to sweat, and I feel so nervous that I can barely listen to what Mr. Hickson is saying. Then I see Minho’s face in front of me, and I swear to god that I will revenge him. Thinking of Minho, I was filled with anger again.
Then he realized that the whole class began to cheer. They were so happy that they were even shouting. “What happened? What are you cheering about?” I asked. Somebody answered, “He won’t be collecting our homework anymore. He said he would just leave it to us”. I am so relieved. Suddenly, I felt sorry for Minho. Maybe I was too harsh on Minho. When I return to my room, I will say that I’m sorry to Minho




*             *             *
2nd person - Han
Junsu could never find his notebook. I never gave his notebook back. However, they soon made up and became friends again. Didn’t they fight because of the notebook? I wonder what happened.